Story for the Week

If you ever choose to be the person who makes me late, just be prepared for me to be mad at you. 🤷‍♀️

Unless it’s truly an emergency and can’t be helped, I hate being late. I would rather arrive somewhere an hour early than be five or ten minutes late. I always have a book to read, so I don’t mind waiting…anywhere. And I don’t like rushing. It sets a mood that I find difficult to shake, and I really don’t like it. I also feel like it’s really disrespectful to whoever you’re meeting wherever you’re going if you show up late.

Before I got married, I was rarely late. I keep everything in a calendar (Never Recovering from My Notebook Obsession). I build my travel time into my calendar blocks, working back from the time I have to arrive somewhere. So if I have a doctor’s appointment at 2, they want me to arrive by 1:45. I know it takes me about 30 minutes to drive there, and I want to leave myself a few extra minutes in case there’s traffic. My calendar entry will start at 1:00 with a note in the description: Appt at 2, arrive by 1:45.

When we go to the theater to see movies, I plan to arrive 30 minutes before the start of the movie. I want time to stop in the bathroom, get drinks from the concessions, and watch the previews. I love the previews. Even now that you choose your own seat, I would rather be comfortably in my chair when the previews start than rushing in while the lights are dimmed trying to figure out where I have to be.

I don’t remember a time when I didn’t dislike being late. After I got married, however, I spent a lot of time being mad at my husband because Dennis was almost always late. I used to say I was never late…and then I got married. Dennis made us late everywhere. And before you suggest I could have just left without him, those were definitely the scenarios described by the phrase “choose your battles.”

Over time, I learned to tell Dennis what time we were leaving the house versus what time we had to be somewhere. And he learned to appreciate some of my reasoning for arriving places on time. When he argued with me about how much he disliked getting to the doctor early only to have to sit and wait, I explained that I didn’t care how long I waited at the doctor. They schedule patients closely together as required by the companies they work for (a discussion for another day).

My rationale is that they could be running behind because they had to spend some extra time with a patient experiencing a serious health issue. I would like to think that I would get the same kind of time if I needed it. I also know that my doctor double and triple books himself so he can see more patients and people don’t have to wait more than six months to get an appointment. I like my doctor, so I’m willing to offer an awful lot of grace.

When Dennis passed away, I didn’t want a traditional urn. He had a bit of an obsession with watches (ironic, I know), so we chose a beautiful mantel clock to hold the ashes. The clock chimes every 15 minutes throughout the day, and the manufacturer is known for making extremely precise clocks. After we selected it, I commented that now Dennis would always be on time. 😬 (We also knew that we wanted to put the clock somewhere out of the way so it couldn’t be accidentally knocked over and broken. It’s on the entertainment center on the highest shelf in the house. Dennis was absolutely terrified of heights. Does that make me a horrible person? 😬😬)

Corinne inherited her father’s…lack of urgency. While she fully understands the importance I place in being on time, she is not nearly as diligent. For the most part, she gives herself extra time to get to work and school. (Actually waking up to her alarms or not turning them off when she thinks she’ll stay awake is a separate conversation.) But casual events don’t seem to carry quite the same importance for her to make sure she’s on time.

This past August, we took some of our friends with us to an indie book convention in Cincinnati (A Summer of Vacations with My Favorite People). We rented an AirBnB about 20 minutes away from the convention center, and the last schedule I saw showed that check-in took place from 9:00-10:00 on the first of two days. I didn’t expect us to get there right at 9:00. I’m not completely unreasonable. But I did want to leave the AirBnB by around 8:45. We needed to stop for breakfast, so I figured it would take us probably 40 minutes or so to get there.

Four of us slept upstairs in the AirBnB. Corinne slept downstairs with her friend Raena. Everyone asked what time we were getting up. I said we were leaving at 8:45, so whatever time they had to get up for that was up to them. Corinne hadn’t seen Raena in a while since Raena goes to school in Michigan, so they spent a lot of time catching up and went to sleep pretty late. The upstairs crew woke up and got ready, and at about 7:45, Abby went downstairs to make sure Corinne and Raena were awake.

Everyone continued getting ready, and around 8:45, Corinne and Raena woke up again. They hustled, and Corinne knew I wasn’t happy. She asked me how mad I was, and I said that the time we arrived at the convention center would determine whether I was actually mad or just mildly annoyed. We parked at 9:56.

As it turned out, the organizers weren’t completely ready for people, so we sat around waiting for the author panels to start anyway. I couldn’t really be mad. And it was a book convention where I would meet one of my favorite authors, so I was pretty much in my happy place. That particular time, she got lucky. 😉

In the book below, the main character gets annoyed at her agent for telling her the wrong time for a meeting because of an accident she witnessed rushing to the meeting.

“You’re on time.”
“I would have been here sooner, but…” I shut up. I don’t explain what prevented me from being early. He seems disinterested as he heads in the same direction as Jeremy.
“The actual meeting isn’t until nine thirty, but I figured you’d be late, so I told you nine.”
I pause, staring at the back of his head.
What the hell, Corey? If he’d told me nine thirty rather than nine, I wouldn’t have witnessed the accident across the street. I wouldn’t have been subjected to a stranger’s blood.
“You coming?” Corey asks, pausing to look back at me.
I bury my irritation. I’m used to doing that when it comes to him.

And I’m sure he’s used to burying his irritation at her always being late, which his why he tells her 30 minutes earlier for important meetings. I would argue that it’s her own fault she was subjected to the stranger’s blood…and everything else that follows. 🤷‍♀️


Book Review

⭐⭐⭐
3 Stars for Verity by Colleen Hoover

338 pages
Publisher: Grand Central Publishing
Publication Date: October 5, 2021
Purchased on Amazon.

Publisher’s Description

Lowen Ashleigh is a struggling writer on the brink of financial ruin when she accepts the job offer of a lifetime. Jeremy Crawford, husband of bestselling author Verity Crawford, has hired Lowen to complete the remaining books in a successful series his injured wife is unable to finish.

Lowen arrives at the Crawford home, ready to sort through years of Verity’s notes and outlines, hoping to find enough material to get her started. What Lowen doesn’t expect to uncover in the chaotic office is an unfinished autobiography Verity never intended for anyone to read. Page after page of bone-chilling admissions, including Verity’s recollection of the night her family was forever altered.

Lowen decides to keep the manuscript hidden from Jeremy, knowing its contents could devastate the already grieving father. But as Lowen’s feelings for Jeremy begin to intensify, she recognizes all the ways she could benefit if he were to read his wife’s words. After all, no matter how devoted Jeremy is to his injured wife, a truth this horrifying would make it impossible for him to continue loving her.

************

Main Characters:

  • Lowen Ashleigh – 31 years old, struggling author who is about to be evicted from her apartment, she has been taking care of her mother who died from colon cancer the previous week, her literary agent has set up a meeting at a publishing company and she is hoping it will get her out of a financial hole
  • Jeremy Crawford – married to Verity Crawford, used to work in real estate, father to five-year-old Crew, their twin daughters died in separate accidents (one from anaphylaxis, one from drowning), he brokers the deal for Lowen to ghost-write the remaining three books in Verity’s successful series
  • Verity Crawford – 36 years old, best-selling author, recently released from a rehabilitation center after a car accident left her incapacitated, has full-time care from nurses during the day, Jeremy takes care of her overnight

Trigger warning: child abuse, child death, attempted abortion

I decided to read this book because I expected to go see the movie. Based on my experience with It Ends With Us (When You Realize You’ve Become a Statistic….), I hoped for a great book experience followed by a fantastic movie experience. I won’t say this was a bad book. But I’ll probably stick with the movie adaptations of Colleen Hoover’s books going forward…if I watch them at all. I haven’t watched the movie yet because of some pretty scathing reviews after it’s release and the fact that, after the movie adaptation, the author changed her mind about the ending of the book she wrote. 🤔

In fairness, I put this book on my list based on a recommendation from a friend without knowing anything about it except that it was being made into a movie. Honestly, the description appealed to me, and the reviews are excellent. Amazon shows it at 4.6 stars, with 91% of nearly 500K ratings of 4 or 5 stars. Goodreads houses more than 4M ratings, 81% of which are 4 or 5 stars. I am definitely in the minority, and I actually might have rated it higher had it not been for the Epilogue.

This is built like a novel within a novel. Verity Crawford is a bestselling author of a successful series of books. Incapacitated by an accident shortly after the second of her and Jeremy’s twin daughters tragically dies, her publisher hires Lowen to ghost-write the last three books in the series. The seriousness of Verity’s condition has not been made public, so Lowen is put forward as a co-writer under a pen name.

Lucky for Lowen, who is being evicted from her apartment after her own mother’s death, Jeremy invites her to stay at the house for a few days. She will use her time there to go through Verity’s office, to find notes about the end of the series. While she rummages through all of Verity’s files, however, she comes across a hidden manuscript that seems to be a memoir or autobiography. Verity’s autobiography seems to show a different side of her and her relationship with Jeremy than Jeremy portrayed.

Throughout the story, Lowen tries to immerse herself in the series she is supposed to be finishing. Alternating with chapters that tell the reader what is happening in the house with Lowen and Jeremy and Crew, we get to read the chapters of Verity’s manuscript as Lowen reads them.

Let me just say that Verity’s manuscript is horrifying, sick, and twisted…which I suppose is the point. But this one made me feel a lot like I felt reading Saving Noah (If You Love Something, Set It Free), which I rated only 1 star. And I also wouldn’t classify this as a romantic thriller. Is there an attraction and a sexual element between Jeremy and Lowen? Yes…absolutely. But I wouldn’t call it romantic. It’s almost as twisted as Verity’s manuscript.

I also feel like Verity became super repetitive with her sexual obsession with Jeremy and her thoughts about motherhood. And Lowen couldn’t make a decision to save her life: I’m falling for Jeremy, I should leave, I need to stop reading the manuscript, I can’t stop reading the manuscript, I want to be with Jeremy, I need to tell Jeremy about the manuscript, I can’t be with Jeremy, I can’t tell Jeremy about the manuscript, I should leave, I should stay, Jeremy there’s a manuscript. 🙄🙄🙄

***SPOILERS*** SPOILERS***SPOILERS***

So let’s talk about my challenges with the book, which I can’t do without spoilers. Granted, the book released in 2016 in its original form, but I’m sure there are plenty of people who haven’t read it.

Throughout the book, Lowen thinks she sees Verity move, look through windows when they’re outside. At some point, she becomes convinced that Verity is faking her condition. Crew mentions talking to his mother. The television gets turned off. The curtains in Verity’s window move. Lowen even thinks she sees Verity standing at the top of the stairs at one point. But then she consistently second guesses herself because Jeremy insists that Verity is truly incapacitated.

The further Lowen gets into Verity’s manuscript, the more she feels the need to finish it to understand Verity’s situation. And the longer she’s in the house, the more she finds herself attracted to Jeremy…and it’s not one-sided. Jeremy seems just as taken with Lowen. And the further Lowen gets into Verity’s manuscript, the more she feels like she might have to tell Jeremy what a horrible woman Verity is.

But the online reader debate between “team manuscript” and “team letter” comes from the end of the book. Verity’s manuscript reveals that she never wanted children because she never wanted anything or anyone to take Jeremy’s attention off of her. She constantly thinks of ways to cause a miscarriage when she’s pregnant with the twins. She considers ways to kill them once they’re born.

At some point Lowen gives the manuscript to Jeremy to read. He is so devastated that he decides that Verity must die herself because of everything she thought and did before her accident. He makes it look like she aspirated in her sleep, but he kills her while Lowen watches. We as readers think it’s the grief and the horror of learning what happened to their daughters.

Seven months after Verity’s death, Jeremy decides to sell the house, and he and Lowen pack up with Crew to move to North Carolina, out of the spotlight. As they’re getting ready to leave, Crew remembers pictures that he made for Verity that were hidden under a floorboard in her room, which prompts Lowen to go explore. She finds a letter written to Jeremy that Verity had written with the intent of him finding it after she disappeared with Crew.

The manuscript, Verity claims in the letter, was a writing exercise that her editor suggested for her to get into the mind of her villains. The idea was for her to be the villain in circumstances derived from her own life. But Jeremy discovered the manuscript and thought it was all true, so he crashed her car into a tree, moved her to the driver’s seat, and expected her not to survive. When he visits the hospital one day and finds her with her eyes open, she fakes a catatonic state…and continues faking it until the day Jeremy finally does kill her.

So now Lowen realizes that she was right all along that Verity was faking. But she also thinks that Jeremy may have killed an innocent women and that she’s involved with—and expecting a child with—a monster. Because he knew about the manuscript all along. So what does she do? Does she go to the police? Does she leave on her own? At the end of the original release, we don’t know. It’s open-ended.

“I have no idea what to believe, so why put him through more anguish? Verity could have written that letter as a way to cover her tracks. It could have been another play at manipulating the situation and everyone involved.
And even if Jeremy really was the reason for her wreck, I can’t blame him. He believed Verity maliciously murdered his child. I can’t even blame him for ultimately following through with her murder when he found out she had been deceiving him about her injuries. Any parent in his position would have done the same.
Should have done the same. We both believed in our hearts that she was a threat to Crew. To us.
No matter which way I look at it, it’s clear that Verity was a master at manipulating the truth. The only question that remains is: Which truth was she manipulating?”

The Epilogue, which was added in 2022, takes place six months after Lowen finds the letter. Hoover has said that she added the Epilogue to provide closure since there was so much discourse about the ambiguity of the ending. But she doesn’t clear up anything in my opinion. The Epilogue deals more with Lowen coming to terms with what Jeremy did, with her own role as a mother, and with her relationship with Jeremy that she constantly compares to Verity. She wants to be the mother Verity wasn’t…for Jeremy.

“I want Jeremy to recognize that I’m much more involved than Verity ever was as a mother—whether she was the manuscript mother or the letter mother, I aim to outdo either version of her.”

When they take Crew to the beach one day, a woman comes by who had been a friend of Verity’s. When Crew lets it slip that Lowen’s baby is his baby sister, the woman realizes that Jeremy and Lowen must have been together when Verity died. Fearing that she will start talking to her friends, Jeremy kills her. Then Lowen begins debating whether she is safe with Jeremy. He killed two women, after all. What if he begins to feel about her the way he felt about Verity? And still she stays!!!

And I don’t even have the desire to go too far into the fact that Crew seems to be written like Damien from The Omen—biting down on a knife so his cuts his mouth open, putting his baby sister outside because she won’t stop crying. I mean, at this rate, the entire family was made up of psychopaths.

Hoover said in an interview about the movie that she saw about seven different endings before they decided on the actual ending. But based on her own opinion about the story—which she wrote—she is “team manuscript,” which makes zero sense to me with the Epilogue. When she makes Jeremy into a two-time murderer (along with the original attempted murder of Verity), Verity immediately became the victim in their entire relationship.

And for the life of me, I don’t understand why Verity didn’t choose to leave at some point under the cover of night. She certainly had the financial means, and Crew is the only one who knew she wasn’t catatonic.


If you enjoyed this post, please comment below. Subscribe for regular updates, and share it with your friends. If you’re interested in starting a conversation, send an email to booksundertheblanket@gmail.com.

As an Amazon affiliate, I earn a small commission at no cost to you when you make a purchase using the links on my site.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.